Tag: Trim

The Tower House Problem

Dr Sarah Kerr, Lecturer in Archaeology at University College Cork and expert grants assessor for the Trust, takes a look at her new focus of study, Tower Houses in Ireland, and the issues involved in researching them.

Tower houses have received considerable attention in recent years, most notably Victoria L McAlister’s monograph on the subject (McAlister 2019). Her work brought to the fore the multiplicity of functions performed by tower houses particularly their crucial role in exploiting the natural environment and contributing to national and international economies. Breen and Raven focused on Gaelic-maintained areas on the long western coast of Ireland and considered late medieval tower houses as the primary expression of secular lordship (Breen et al. 2017, 151). Both important pieces of work drew upon – and contributed to – the landscape turn in castle studies by exploring the wider, often maritime, environment.

Subscribe to our quarterly newsletter

Despite these recent developments there are arguably a number of issues which inhibit our understanding of tower houses and may even restrict future avenues of research. Summarised as the tower house problem, these issues are highlighted in the hope that greater awareness may assist averting the limitations they impose. There was a vast – albeit unknown – number of tower houses in use contemporaneously in late medieval Ireland. Harold Leask, (d. 1964) the first Inspector of National Monuments in Ireland, calculated that some three thousand tower houses were documented in the Ordnance Survey maps. Therefore he provided the minimum number of how many existed prior to the mid-nineteenth century (Leask 1941; McAlister 2019, 12; Sherlock 2011, 115). Estimations have varied to over 7000 while the Archaeological Survey of Ireland list approximately 1300 known examples (Sherlock 2011, 115; Barry 1993; Barry 2008b, 129). The result is descriptions of Ireland as ‘the most castellated country in Europe’ (Barry 2008) or ‘one of the most castellated parts’ of the Irish and British Isles (Cairns 1987, 31; O’Conor 1998, 25). Certain areas represent this clearly, particularly in Munster and Leinster, with clusters of tower houses in close proximity to one another.

This vast archaeological record has posed a problem for archaeologists and much work of the 1990s and early 2000s focused on creating types and sub-types to dissect the record into manageable portions. Creation of types based on architectural similarities is useful for understanding individual examples and provincial trends but it doesn’t address the phenomenon of the tower house, the vast numbers and clustering in certain areas. As a method it is therefore limited in its usefulness. In addition, it can led to creating boxes and trying to make examples fit therein, which has obvious shortcomings and may result in overlooking the uniqueness of each example.

Subscribe to our quarterly newsletter

There is a problem more fundamental to tower house research that needs addressed: should they be considered castles? Tower houses are often referred to as castles, small castles or a type of castle and this seems rational as some examples were described as castellum, cúirt or fortalicium by their contemporaries (McAlister 2019, 15). Their architecture supports this classification, as they display features found frequently at larger castles, such as those built by the Anglo-Normans in Ireland around two centuries before tower house building commenced. These accepted castle attributes include machicolations, battlements, arrow loop windows, narrow entrances and thick walls. Other common castle features identified less commonly at tower houses include yetts (iron gate), hagioscopes (squint at the door allowing a line of sight outside), bawns (enclosure wall), adjoined towers, and some ornamentation such as hood mouldings.  

Figure 1: Leamcon (Blackcastle) Castle, copyright Dr Sarah Kerr

This is where the comparison ends, however, as the form of tower houses was distinct from Anglo-Norman castles. Tower houses were comparatively narrow towers comprising as least three storeys, such as Leamcon locally known as Blackcastle (Figure 1) in West Cork. A batter was required to aid stability (thicker walls at the base) which created slightly larger rooms at the upper levels than those on the lower levels. Windows increased in size with height, with small and sparse windows lower on the façade to create a solid and strong base. Vaults were invariably included within to further aid their structural integrity. These were often at ground-floor level but vaults on other floors were also commonplace. At the upper levels there was a wall-walk, pitched wooden roof and crenelated parapet. The latter could take the form of stepped merlons, often attributed to the Gaelic founders, or the square-crenels type, built primarily by English and Scottish settlers. In addition to the clear architectural differences between earlier stone-built castles of the Anglo-Norman period and tower house, their functions were different. Anglo-Norman castles were tools in colonialism (for example, Trim in Figure 2) and displays of the same whereas tower houses were built by Anglo-Irish and Gaelic elites, merchants and rural landowners, lay and ecclesiastical lords during a period of relative peace and economic prosperity. Some comparison between the types have focused on the towers (donjons or keeps) that were the focal point of Anglo-Norman castles however conclusions are limited due to the scarcity of work carried out on tower house settlements; that is, in their immediate surrounds.

Figure 2: Trim Castle, copyright Dr Sarah Kerr

I have recently made the argument that, combined, the above issues create the tower house problem and awareness of this is required to continue studying these buildings in an effective way. The tower house problem is typified in West Cork, a culturally distinct area west of Cork City that encompasses the south-west coastline of Ireland and comprises large peninsulas with numerous small inlets and embayments. The area is dense with extant and lost late medieval tower houses; Figure 3, is a photograph taken from Rincolisky (Whitehall) tower house with Kilcoe tower house visible across the bay. Recent fieldwork sought to examine the density of tower houses, examples of which are sometimes referred to as the ‘West Cork type’, and consider the phenomenon through the lens of spatial analysis, placename evidence and architectural analysis – results forthcoming. The fieldwork however has presented broader questions about whether we should consider tower houses castles. Either way, to do so or not should be justified perhaps with reflection upon terminological limitations. Accepting the distinctiveness of tower houses might be more productive in further understanding the reasons behind their construction and use – and crucially overcoming the tower house problem.  

Figure 3: Whitehall and Kilcoe Tower Houses, copyright Dr Sarah Kerr

Subscribe to our quarterly newsletter

Barry, T. 1993. The archaeology of the tower house in later medieval Ireland. In H. Andersson & J. Weinberg (eds) The Study of Medieval Archaeology, 211–18. Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell International

Barry, T. 2008a. The study of medieval Irish castle: a bibliographic survey. Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy: Archaeology, Culture, History, Literature 108 (C): p.115-136.

Barry, T. 2008b. The study of medieval Irish castles: a bibliographic survey. Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy. Section C: Archaeology, Celtic Studies, History, Linguistics, Literature 108C: p.115–136.

Breen, C., & Raven, J. 2017. Maritime Lordship in Late-Medieval Gaelic Ireland. Medieval Archaeology 61(1): p.149–182.

Cairns, C.T. 1987. Irish tower houses: A Co. Tipperary case study. Dublin: Trinity College Dublin.

Leask, H.G. 1941. Irish castles and castellated houses Revised edition. Dundalk: Dundalgan Press.

McAlister, V. 2019. The Irish tower house: Society, economy and environment, c. 1300-1650 1st edition. Manchester (GB): P648 – MANCHESTER UNIV PR.

O’Conor, K.D. 1998. The Archaeology of Medieval Rural Settlement in Ireland. Dublin: Royal Irish Academy.

Sherlock, R. 2011. The evolution of the Irish tower-house as a domestic space. Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy. Section C: Archaeology, Celtic Studies, History, Linguistics, Literature 111C: p.115–140.

Viewscapes from Trim Castle

Scott Stull, archaeology lecturer at SUNY Cortland, looks at the results of an interdisciplinary led by Physicist Michael “Bodhi” Rogers, that he took part in looking at the landscape and viewscapes of Trim Castle.

Trim Castle, in County Meath, Ireland, was built starting in 1187 by the De Lacy family as part of the Anglo-Norman conquest of Ireland. After a long history of conflict, disputed ownership, expansion, change, and decay, the castle was finally abandoned in the mid-sixteenth century when it was described as being full of cattle and dung. The medieval landscape around Trim is remarkably well preserved, including the walls of the town, a fourteenth-century bridge over the River Boyne, a variety of religious institutions, and the farmlands, called the Porchfields, which still have their ridge and furrow plough marks.

In 2016 and 2017, Michael “Bodhi” Rogers led a team of students to digitally record Trim Castle and the surrounding landscape. That scanning project was described in Archaeology Ireland (https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/26565802.pdf). The results of that project allowed further study and analysis of the landscape, and specifically the viewscape, of Trim Castle. In a three-way interdisciplinary project, Scott Stull (archaeology), Michael “Bodhi” Rogers (physics), and Michael Twomey (medieval literature) looked at Trim Castle and how the views from the castle were carefully constructed as part of the creation of medieval power and authority.

Trim Castle showing the Dublin Gate (foreground) and Keep (background), image credit Michael “Bodhi” Rogers

The starting point for this study, which is a chapter of the upcoming volume, Bailey, Kinsella, Thomas (eds) Architectural Representation in Medieval Textual and Material Culture (Arc Humanities Press, 2022), is the concept of the cultural landscape. The cultural landscape is how people shape a landscape and put meaning on it, to influence perception, behaviour, and patterns of social interaction. It can be practical, such as food production, or it can be tied to belief systems, such as religious sites, places associated with an ethnic or group identity, or associated with structures of power and authority. Castles, while often associated with military activity, embody most of these elements, and as part of the cultural landscape help create beliefs that support those practices and perceptions.

Viewscapes are a specific aspect of a cultural landscape, and in this case are the views from the castle. At Trim, the castle is placed to oversee the town, roads, bridge, farm fields, and religious institutions. There are a variety of ways to identify and record viewscapes, such as with mapping and GIS systems (for example: Lisa Karen McManama-Kearin, The Use of GIS in Determining the Role of Visibility in the Siting of Early Anglo-Norman Castles in Ireland, BAR British Series 575, Oxford: British Archaeological Reports, 2013). Our study, overseen by Bodhi Rogers, used ground-based lidar to make a 3D record of Trim Castle and its surroundings. The result of the recording is effectively a 3D photograph which you can examine from any angle or point in space. This allows us to see from windows which are inaccessible physically, or from spots which have been lost due to decay or collapse over time.

Digital record of Trim Castle showing the view from the Constable’s Tower toward the Dublin Gate and River Boyne, image credit Michael “Bodhi” Rogers.

While a useful modern tool, viewscapes were a fundamental part of the medieval understanding of castles. We see castles used as viewing platforms, as symbolic places of literal and figurative elevation, and as part of medieval romances where the view from the window represents both the desire and distance of a romantic attraction. In many cases, the lady views the desired knight from the castle window, and the knight is inspired by the glimpse of the lady in the window, affirming the ideals of courtly love. Religious allegories have the castle as a tower of morality, and the viewscape is often overlooking humanity in all its faults and mundanities. By looking at medieval literature, we can gain an understanding of the medieval mindset.

Combining the physical context of a castle with the medieval mindset allows us to gain a more complete understanding of medieval life. The nobility used castles as structures of power and created a cultural landscape which made that system of power seem normal and natural. Castles were a central part of everyday life in medieval Europe, and the lived experience of medieval people was shaped by the created landscapes in and around a castle. At Trim, the castle overlooked the social and economic centres of the community, from the Porchfields to the monasteries. The viewscapes from the castle were specifically created to reinforce the position of the De Lacy family and its successors over the lands and cultural landscape in Trim. Trim castle was the dominant element in both the physical and social landscape.

Subscribe to our quarterly newsletter

Feature Image: Trim Castle Keep and the Sheepgate (foreground), image credit: Scott Stull